Controversial judgment over detention of undocumented asylum seekers spotlighted

The Midday Report with Mandy Wiener · 17 November 2026 · 7m

Speaker 1: A three-day legal fight currently underway in the courts over undocumented asylum seekers. And this Speaker 1: is all to do about whether or not asylum applications can be processed while applicants Speaker 1: remain in detention. Dimakatsu Lashoro, EWN reporter, is on this case for us. Dimakatsu, good Speaker 1: afternoon to you. Firstly, explain to us what exactly is, what is this application about? Speaker 2: Okay, Mandy, just a bit of background. The dispute emanates from 2018 where a court Speaker 2: recognized that people that enter South Africa are not automatically excluded from the refugee protections Speaker 2: if they enter the country illegally. And, you know, then it was a matter of Speaker 2: determining how their protections are protected because they would have entered the country illegally without Speaker 2: any requirements that they would have met when going to Home Affairs. And then there Speaker 2: was a 2023 case that allowed their detention while authorities were establishing their identity and Speaker 2: processing them in terms of our own immigration and refugee acts. And then we had Speaker 2: the July 2026 constitutional court, which, if you remember, led to... Sorry, there's a bit Speaker 2: of noise here. led to protests in part of the country, which was brought by Speaker 2: the NPO group Skalabrini, which removed those barriers that Home Affairs had placed to say Speaker 2: that if you're coming to South Africa, you have to meet certain requirements. And that Speaker 2: then meant that people who came to South Africa illegally are now able to access Speaker 2: the system. And that means not that they automatically gain refugee status, but they are Speaker 2: there by Home Affairs. So that has obviously opened…

Listen in Visual Radio →

← All episodes of The Midday Report with Mandy Wiener